Gender Transformation

© 2017 Arturo Sanabria, Courtesy of Photoshare

Gender transformation” refers to efforts to change gender and social norms to address inequalities in power and privilege between persons of different genders, in order to free all people from harmful and destructive norms. These norms include gender roles, expectations, stereotypes, and harmful attitudes, customs, and practices, including gender-based violence (MenEngage Alliance, 2017). Gender transformation enables individuals to question and critically analyze issues of gender inequality and injustice, and provides them with opportunities to challenge harmful norms.

What Are the Benefits?

  • Gender equitable communities ensure that all adolescents and young people have better sexual and reproductive health (SRH) outcomes: Gender norms are established early in life and have several negative consequences (Blum et al., 2017). For girls these include child marriage, early pregnancy, dropping out of school, exposure to STIs including HIV, and vulnerability to gender-based violence. For boys these include engaging in or being affected by violence, accidents and injuries, and substance use. Adopting gender transformative approaches results in more gender equitable communities that reject destructive gender and sexual norms for all, improving access to SRHR information and services and enabling better SRHR outcomes (Chandra-Mouli et al., 2017).
  • Addressing urban girls and young women’s particular vulnerabilities ensures better SRH: The “urban health penalty”—the likelihood of poor urban young people being at greater risk of negative health outcomes—affects early adolescent females in particular. This is due to several factors, including a lack of adequate clean water, sanitation and hygiene; lack of knowledge and access to SRH services; and limited life skills. Evidence from Chennai, India reveals that these result in menstrual morbidity and reproductive or urinary tract infections (GAGE, 2017). Factors like child marriage, limited education and livelihood opportunities, social isolation and marginalization, and unsafe sexual relations over which girls have limited or no control contribute to girls’ higher risks of negative health outcomes, including HIV (Erulkar et al., 2012).
  • Challenging gender norms increases contraceptive uptake: Gender norms in most contexts require young men to be knowledgeable about sex and young girls to be sexually ignorant. This makes it difficult for either to access adequate SRH information and services, in addition to other barriers that young women and men face in having their sexual and reproductive rights fulfilled (USAID, FP HIPs, 2015). The same norms also deter young women from obtaining, carrying or negotiating the use of condoms (STEP UP, 2014). Working on changing these gender norms can enable better access to SRH information and services, including to contraception, and a decrease in violence (icddr,b, 2014).

How to Implement?

Promote community dialogue on SRH and gender norms
Engage with community members on sexual and reproductive health and rights, gender and sexual norms, expectations around fertility (especially for newly married girls and young women), and the importance of couples’ communication and joint decision-making. For specific kinds of issues or norms, you will need to be strategic about which community member or change agents you choose to work with, for example:

  • For harmful gender norms like child, early or forced marriage, or female genital cutting/mutilation, working with faith or religious leaders can have a strong impact within conservative societies (IRH, 2016).
  • On issues of early pregnancy, spacing, and couples’ communication, working with mothers-in-law can be effective, as they are often the decision-makers on the number and spacing of children and young married women’s access to contraception (E2A, 2014).

A useful tool to enable communication targeted at parents and community members to influence the promotion of girls’ education and reduction in domestic violence is PROMISES by Save the Children. Another useful toolkit on engaging and mobilizing the community is the Community Action Cycle: Implementation Guide by the Gender Roles, Equality and Transformations (GREAT) Project.

Build girls’ and young women’s human and social capital
This involves bringing together girls’ groups to meet regularly, learn leadership and life skills, understand their sexual and reproductive health and rights, and be mentored by someone who is a bit older. Once you have worked with the community and family to generate support for SRH, ask them to allow girls to be involved in peer support groups. Having trained mentors builds credibility with the gatekeepers to ensure girls’ involvement in the program (GAGE, 2017). Mentors can give out health vouchers to the girls, offer to accompany them to the health center, and act as protectors and advocates. Participation in peer support groups builds girls’ self-efficacy and agency. Refer to Population Council’s toolkit on Girl-Centered Program Design to get a comprehensive understanding on how to do this effectively.
Educate boys and young men on SRHR, including gender
The importance and need for involving males in gender transformative dialogue and interventions is well-documented. Evaluation of the SAFE program in urban slums in Bangladesh revealed that involving males and females (as opposed to just involving females) had the most impact on reducing physical and economic violence (icddr,b, 2014). Educate boys and young men on sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) and facilitate gender-equitable SRH practicesProgram H | M | D is a well-evaluated curriculum on engaging boys and young men to achieve gender equality, as is Engaging Men and Boys in Gender Equality and Health: A Global Toolkit for Action.

Example: Working with boys and young men in Mumbai, India

A Systematic Review of Positive Youth Development Programs in Low- and Middle-Income Countries by USAID documents “Parivartan,” a program implemented in Mumbai from 2008 to 2012. It worked with boys and young men through cricket clubs, with male coaches training them on challenging and questioning norms around masculinity, respect for girls and women, and preventing violence against women. The program had positive effects on participants’ beliefs on gender equity and traditional notions of masculinity. This review also emphasized that programs targeting activities to males and females to address unequal gender norms were the most effective in reducing gender inequality (USAID, 2017).

Address specific gender discriminations or injustice
Depending on the group of young people you are reaching with your program, there may be specific issues to be addressed, for example:

  • Pregnant girls or young mothers having to drop out of school. Supporting young mothers to stay in or return to school ensures that they are still able to gain the skills and resources required for good SRH outcomes despite an early pregnancy (E2A, 2014) .
  • You may need to address girls’ and young women’s lower socio-economic status where transactional sex is an important economic resource for them. A large service delivery improvement effort in Tanzania failed to demonstrate an impact on contraceptive use among young people because it did not address issues of transactional sex among young girls and social norms of masculinity (USAID, FP HIPs, 2015).
  • Gender-based violence (GBV) can negatively impact contraceptive uptake. Where there is high prevalence of GBV, there would be a need for multisectoral GBV prevention and support interventions.

What Is the Evidence?

  • A Population Council study on incorporating male reproductive health services into female-focused family planning programs in Bangladesh concluded that it did not discourage women from attending clinics; increased uptake of services from both sexes; enabled service providers to increase their technical knowledge about male reproductive health problems, particularly with regard to STIs and RTIs (Population Council, 2004).
  • Group-based mentoring programs have demonstrated improvements across multiple outcomes including RH knowledge and behavior, academic achievement, financial behavior, and social networks, as well as decreases in the experience of violence. The most successful mentoring programs incorporated components aimed at improving girls’ and young women’s protective assets. For example, some programs provided access to safe, social spaces outside the home where participants were able to develop and strengthen their peer network. Others included the delivery of curriculum-based education on RH, gender and financial literacy. Finally, more frequent mentor/mentee meetings (once per week) over a longer period of time (6 months or longer) were associated with improved RH outcomes (Plourde et al., 2017).
  • An intervention that includes multiple components operating at different levels of the ecological model is ‘CHOICES’ in Nepal. This had a component on communication on gender inequality between parents and children at the household level, and one at the community level (Save the Children, 2009). Evaluation of this program demonstrated improvements in attitudes of adolescents on sharing household tasks, control and dominance, and girls’ education (Chandra-Mouli et al., 2017).

Take An Assessment and Get a Certificate

Helpful Tips

  • Comprehensive sexuality education programs should include an empowerment approach with an emphasis on gender and rights. Young people with more egalitarian attitudes about gender roles are more likely to delay sexual debut, use condoms and practice contraception.
  • You may need to provide safety from sexual harassment or assault to girls and young women who want to access your interventions or services. For example, enable them to travel in groups, provide a trustworthy chaperone or vehicle, etc. as exemplified in the Adolescent Girls Initiative of the World Bank; or using an “official” space as done in the Biruh Tesfa program in Ethiopia.
  • Programs for female adolescents should build their social capital (e.g., support networks of peers, work colleagues, teachers, or others who they can rely on for providing information, advice, guidance and support) and inclusion (participation in and contribution to social, economic and political life). Provide opportunities for them to stay in school and obtain positive and non-exploitive forms of work also reduces the likelihood of early sexual debut and sexual coercion.

Youth Participation

  • Engage young women and men in dialogue about gender, keeping in mind that females and males have different lived experiences of participation. For example, females have voiced a need for for physical, psychological, and digital security systems to protect against forms of backlash and violence due to security risks associated with participation in AYSRH activities.

Data Management

  • Ensure that all monitoring and evaluation data is gender-disaggregated, including by several different gender identities.

Multisectoral Collaboration

  • Partner with feminist and women’s organizations who have a holistic focus on women’s empowerment.
  • Make linkages with health and legal services for those who experience gender-based violence.

q

Challenges

  • Programs should not focus on only transferring knowledge on gender and SRHR, but also find ways of affecting individual decisions and behavior.
  • Changing individuals’ behavior and beliefs is possible through short-term programmatic interventions. However, changing harmful gender and sexual norms in a community or a society can take generations. Measuring and reporting on progress over longer timeframes can be a challenge. To learn more in-depth about how community and social norms change occurs, you can refer to Social Norms and Girls’ Well-Being: Linking Theory and Practice by Data2X.
  • Programmers must think through the implications and risks for individuals when they return to their communities. For example, men who adopt more gender equitable norms and behaviors may face discrimination by other men in their communities and be perceived as “weak.” This is yet another reason to work on multiple socio-ecological levels to change norms.

Tools Related to This Approach

Some examples of curricula and toolkits that have been evaluated to demonstrate gender transformation are:


Related Approaches

References

See a listing of all AYSRH references.