Positive Policy & Legal Environment

by | Dec 22, 2017

Dashboard Advocating for Youth-Friendly Cities Positive Policy & Legal Environment

AYSRH Toolkit

Advocating for Youth-Friendly Cities

Positive Policy & Legal Environment

© 2014 Jignesh Patel , Courtesy of Photoshare

What Are the Benefits?

  • Positive laws and policies raise the “rights consciousness” of youth, empowering them with the knowledge that they are entitled to SRH services and information.
  • Laws and policies have the potential to influence social norms; if positive, they can help start discussions in communities where harmful norms persist. 
  • Laws and policies that positively articulate young people’s rights to access SRH services and information close loopholes that allow health providers to define their own restrictive criteria for access.
  • Positive SRH laws and policies provide a basis for youth to seek redress for violations of their human rights, where possible. 
  • Laws and policies that facilitate youth access to contraception promote their participation in and control over their health decision-making.

How to Implement?

Global Human Rights Policy Framework

There are many areas of the law that impact upon the provision of and access to sexual and reproductive health services and information. The World Health Organization has set out a framework for ensuring human rights through the supply of contraceptive services and information, against which national laws and policies can be measured. The framework consists of a set of standards and principles and recommendations for how, practically, they should be integrated into policy and practice.

National and Sub-National Legal & Policy Frameworks

Many areas of law and policy impact youth access to SRH services and information; some impact directly, while others have an indirect influence. Below is a short, non-exhaustive list of the different areas of law and policy to keep in mind when implementing adolescent and youth sexual and reproductive health (AYSRH) programs.

Area of law How it impacts service provision
Sexual consent Sexual consent laws may determine the age at which a person can legally consent to sexual activity, as defined in the law. In many places, this is set at 16 or 18 years of age, though it may be different for same-sex sexual activity.
Rape Criminal law defines what type of conduct is considered “rape.” In many places, sex with a young woman under a certain age (e.g., 16) is criminalized in every circumstance; this is sometimes known as “statutory rape.” These provisions are often interpreted as setting the minimum age of sexual consent. These laws may also be gendered, in that young men’s experiences of rape are excluded from the legal definition.
Child protection Child protection laws may place a duty of care on health providers to report certain information to third parties (e.g., police, social services) if they believe harm will come to a child in their care. In some contexts, health providers may be required to report children under a certain age who are engaged in sexual activity.
Medical consent Medical consent laws often determine an age at which a person can independently consent to medical services. In some places, different ages apply to invasive procedures (e.g., surgery) and non-invasive ones. At times, the age of medical consent can be different for SRH services than for other health services.
Age of majority Age of majority laws set the age at which young people are considered to be legal adults; this is often 18 years. In some contexts, the age of majority is confused with the age at which young people are legally able to consent to sex or access SRH services. It also influences how adults view young people under the age of majority.
Age of marriage Age of marriage is the age at which a person can legally consent to marriage. The internationally-accepted minimum age of marriage is 18, although in some jurisdictions marriage below this age is allowed under customary law or in cases where parents give their consent. In some places, spousal consent is needed in order for women to access contraceptives even where their use is now legal before marriage.
SRH SRH laws specify the services to be provided by the government to the population. The law  may also mandate certain agencies (e.g., ministries of health) to provide services. In addition to primary legislation (acts, statutes), some countries also set out secondary legislation (policies, regulations, strategies, orders) that provide more detail as to how the primary legislation is to be implemented.
Comprehensive sexuality education (CSE) CSE laws set out the topics to be included and the age groups that will receive CSE in schools, as well as the qualifications required of educators. Good CSE laws also make provisions for out-of-school young people, which is of great importance in urban environments.

Advocacy

Step 1: Assess the legal and policy framework in your context

The first step in undertaking advocacy is to identify the problem. Assess existing national and sub-national laws and policies. Compare and contrast them with international human rights norms and evidence of what works with regard to young people’s sexual and reproductive health.

With TCI-supported States, TCI Nigeria conducted the Policy Environment Score (PES) to assess the degree to which each State’s policy environment supports the reproductive health of the population, with specific focus on access to high-quality family planning services, adolescent health, and other reproductive health services. To learn more about their findings, check out the full report, which includes the questionnaire.

 

Other TCI hubs relied on findings from PRB’s Youth Family Planning Policy Scorecard as their starting point.
Step 2: Assess the legal and policy framework’s implementation and impact

The second step is to determine the extent to which national and sub-national laws and policies are being implemented in practice, and what the impact is on youth. Positive, well-articulated laws and policies may not be currently implemented; this may be because of a lack of financial or human resources, lack of political will, norms and stigma, or low legal literacy. An important part of this step is speaking with youth, perhaps using focus groups or interviews, to determine how laws and policies impact their ability to seek and access SRH services, information, and education.

Research: Over-protected and Under-served (Senegal)

In 2012-2013, Coram Children’s Legal Center (CCLC) and the International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF) carried out research to determine how laws and policies affected youth access to SRH services. The methodology centered on youth’s voices, as well as those of providers and parents, in understanding how laws act as barriers or facilitators to services. The results show a discord between several laws and youth’s realities, including a law setting the age of sexual consent at 16. A law clearly affirming youth rights to contraceptive services was seen as an opportunity to advocate for better implementation and access.
Step 3: Understand the avenues for accountability and integrate accountability into AYSRH programs

All young people have the rights to accountability and redress. Accountability mechanisms may exist in the legislative, executive, and judicial branches of government, while social accountability initiatives provide opportunities for communities to monitor the implementation of SRH law and policy. In the context of SRH, social accountability is also referred to as a “set of tools citizens can use to influence the quality of service delivery by holding providers to account” (Evidence Project, 2014). These tools include:

  • Complaint mechanisms, which are formal channels for youth to express dissatisfaction with a service and demand redress.
  • Citizen charters that articulate guidelines for the youth client and provider relationship, providing standards a client can expect and demand.
  • Citizen report cards, which are participatory surveys that solicit youth’s feedback on the performance of public services.
  • Social audits that engage youth, users of services, or civil society organizations in collecting and publicly sharing information on available resources for service delivery and public works.
  • Community scorecards that combine social audits and citizen report cards, compiling information from users and service providers about a particular service. Data is reviewed to allow for immediate feedback and action plan development

 

All SRH programs should have established accountability mechanisms that provide a continuous feedback loop on quality, access, and human rights. At the very least, service-providing institutions can ensure that they have charters of clients’ rights and accompanying complaint mechanisms for clients whose rights are violated. On a larger scale, programs may wish to work with youth to organize citizen hearings or conduct inquiries into rights violations.

 

Step 4: Develop an advocacy strategy with youth

Adopt a systematic, step-by-step approach to building out an advocacy strategy with a group of stakeholders, including youth. The strategy development process should include identification of the problem, target audiences, goals, objectives, activities, and indicators. Prioritize the development of key messages; see page 10 of the Reproductive Health Supplies Coalition’s Youth People and Contraceptive Access: An advocacy and communications toolkit.

TCI’s Success Advocating for Youth-Friendly Cities

  • In Nigeria, TCI provided technical assistance to the Federal Ministry of Health to review the National Standards and Minimum Service Package for Adolescent and Youth-Friendly Health Services policy. A member of the TCI team moved the motion for the adoption of that policy, which has nine criteria that have been set out and nationally accepted to guide implementers of AYSRH programs.
  • The County Government of Kilifi has adapted the TCI AYSRH Toolkit in developing the County Adolescent & Young Persons Sexual Reproductive Health, Rights & HIV Strategic Plan 2019-2022. Some of the interventions in the Strategic Plan include Adolescent and Youth Friendly Services, Out of Facility Service Delivery, and Integration of Services within Facility. All partners implementing AYSRH activities must align with the county strategy, therefore spreading the reach of TCI innovations.

Tips

  • The end goal is not the enactment of a better law or policy; rather, the implementation of a better law or policy. Advocacy can also focus on ensuring the implementation of an existing law or policy to its fullest extent. 
  • Advocate for laws and policies that positively articulate the rights of youth and the responsibilities of those in authority. 
  • Find champions within the institutions, agencies, and ministries you are working with who can help you navigate the processes of legal and policy reform and/or advocacy.
  • The informal nature of some urban settlements means that governments may not officially take responsibility for providing health services in them. Advocate for youth living in such settlements (e.g., slum areas) to be treated as citizens with the same human rights as all others.
  • When defining legal barriers, think not only about the laws that directly restrict youth access, but also those that reinforce harmful norms that perpetuate stigma around youth sexuality, pregnancy, and parenthood.

What is the Evidence?

  • A strong policy framework should require health care providers to offer a full range of contraceptive methods with no restrictions, and include policies permitting youth to access contraception without parental or spousal consent. An enabling policy environment should include affirmative language and/or specific operational guidelines to support effective interventions.
  • Where guidance on policy and expectations for providers is incomplete or confusing, it may contribute to reinforcing restrictive practices that adhere to providers’ own perceptions and expectations. For example, a study in Senegal found that even though there were no official age-related restrictions on youth access to SRH services, in practice, providers often imposed their own.
  • Investments that contribute to building an enabling environment for adolescent programming often include ensuring legal rights, policies, and guidelines that respect, protect, and fulfill youth’s human rights to contraceptive information, products, and services regardless of age, sex, marital status, or parity.
  • An evaluation of the SAFE program in the slums of Dhaka, Bangladesh highlighted the importance of the integration of legal services with SRH services for young women, given the high prevalence of gender-based violence in the community.
  • There is a balance to be struck between protection and autonomy when it comes to youth SRH. At the same time, there should be recognition that the provision of services and information constitutes protection for youth.

Take An Assessment and Get a Certificate

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Helpful Tips

Youth Participation
  • Provide solid examples of advocacy “wins” for youth advocates alongside the supporting activities and interventions that helped achieve them.  
Data Management
  • Document advocacy processes to allow other advocates to learn from your experiences and mistakes.
  • Collect data to help policy makers understand whether their policies and laws are having the intended effect, including from the perspective of youth.
Multisectoral Collaboration
  • Partner with groups of women and feminist lawyers who are familiar with processes for legal and policy reform.

q

Challenges

  • Look for windows of opportunity, especially at the sub-national level where laws and policies are put into action. What policies and guideline reviews are currently underway that you may be able to influence? 
  • With advocacy efforts, there is a continued need to monitor the implementation of positive, rights-promoting laws and policies. 
  • The processes associated with changing laws and policies can be convoluted and, at times, hostile to civil society organizations.

Resources

Legal Assessment Tools and Resources
Advocacy Tools
Country Resources

Nigeria

Senegal

India

Kenya

 

Tanzania

References

See a listing of all AYSRH references.

Back to AYSRH Toolkit
Approach Content
Previous Approach
Back to Program Area
Next Approach
TCI U Menu